Black Cutworm Management in 2012 - Ohio

A mild winter followed by warm spring conditions have resulted in the early arrival of black cutworm moths (BCW, Agrostis ipsilon), which creates the potential for BCW larvae damage this season. If larvae are present when corn emerges, corn seedlings can be clipped at the soil surface when the BCW larvae feed. To avoid stand loss from clipped seedlings, persistent scouting is needed to help determine if economic thresholds have been met. BCW do not typically overwinter in the Corn Belt. Adult moths overwinter in coastal areas of the Gulf of Mexico and migrate northward in the spring on strong winds from the south to lay eggs. Corn can be clipped by BCW from emergence through the V5 (five leaf) growth stage.
 
 
 

Corn at Highest Risk

 
Adult BCW moths lay eggs where there is a food source. They prefer weeds, such as winter annuals, over corn. Fields that contain chickweed are especially susceptible. Therefore, if a field is weed free at planting, it will not be desirable. Economic injury is more likely in fields that are in the VE-V4 (1-4 leaf) growth stage. Fields that are most at risk for BCW damage are fields with:
 
  • Poorly drained and low lying areas
  • Natural vegetation nearby
  • Late tillage
  • Reduced tillage
  • Weeds prior to planting
  • Late-planted corn
  • Corn planted after soybean
 

Damage occurs when weed hosts are destroyed and BCW larvae begin feeding on corn because it is the only food source available. For fields that are high risk for BCW damage, identification and scouting are key for proper management.

 
 

Identification

 
BCW larvae vary from light gray to black and are about 1.5 inches long when fully grown. Numerous convex skin granules make the larvae appear shiny and "greasy".
 

 

 
Dingy cutworm (DCW) larvae may also be present in fields. However, this cutworm usually feeds on leaves and does not cause cutting problems in fields. Larger cutworms found at the beginning of the BCW cutting dates are often DCW because the DCW overwinters in the larva stage. BCW can be distinguished from DCW by the four tubercles (spots) on each body segment3. BCW have two tubercles that are small and two that are larger (Figure 1). DCW have four tubercles on each body segment that are the same size.
 

BCW

 
 

Scouting

Fields should be scouted for BCW from the time corn emerges until the V5 growth stage. Plants cut below the soil by BCW may be partially pulled under the soil and can appear as if angled out of the ground surface. These plants wilt and discolor as they die. In addition to cut or missing plants, leaf feeding is an early indication of BCW damage (Figure 2). When scouting, larvae can be found by digging in the soil near a damaged plant and the larvae growth stage can be estimated by measuring body length. Ohio State University recommends checking 20 plantings in 5 locations, once a week, for damage4. Plant population should be noted so that the percent of plants being injured can be calculated. Collecting a number of BCW larvae is also recommended to help determine the predominant stage of larval development.

Economic/Action Threshold

Damage from 1st-3rd instar larvae (smaller than 1/2 of an inch) is typically minimal with minor leaf feeding on the edge of corn seedling leaves. Cutting damage is caused by 4th instar larvae or larger (1/2-2 inches long) and plants can be cut at or below the soil surface. Ohio State University recommends a rescue treatment when4:
 
  • 3% or more of the plants have been cut or tunneled
  • corn plants are in the 2nd- to 6th-leaf stage
  • larvae are still one inch or less in length
 

Due to the high market price of corn and fluctuations in inputs, Iowa State University has a dynamic action threshold. The action threshold calculation determines when it is economical to treat for BCW based on plant population, expected yield, anticipated market value, and the cost of control:

 

http://www.extension.iastate.edu/CropNews/2009/0527hodgson.htm

 

Corn clipped below ground is more likely to die. If corn is clipped above ground, it may survive, but it has a higher risk for disease infection. Wet soils often favor above-ground clipping. Once corn is at the V5 or V6 growth stage, it is less susceptible to BCW damage.

 

Management

Genuity® SmartStax® corn products have a mode of action which can provide control of BCW. Traits from these corn products are complimented with Acceleron® Seed Treatment Products, which include clothianidin insecticide to provide additional suppression for black cutworm. Use of these new technologies has the potential to reduce the risk of stand loss from BCW.
 

Starting with a clean seed bed is also a good management option for BCW. BCW larvae cannot survive if weeds are tilled or treated with a herbicide 2-3 weeks before corn emergence. Applying a pre-plant a Roundup® agricultural herbicide can help keep the seed bed clean. Additionally, a fall application of a Roundup® agricultural herbicide tank mixed with 2-4,D can be an effective way to manage winter annual weeds. Fall herbicide applications can be more effective than spring applications in controlling winter annual weeds such as common chickweed and purple deadnettle.

 

Preventative insecticides may be another management option, although many extension offices question their worth due to the sporadic nature of BCW. However, an insecticide rescue treatment is recommended when thresholds are met (Table 1). Follow label directions and make sure that insecticide treatments comply with insect resistance management requirements.

 


​​